The passages in the Torah
that teach us about the punishments for performing forbidden activities on Shabbat
are as follows:
You are to keep the Shabbat, for it is holy to you; whoever profanes it is to be put to death, for whoever performs work on it, that soul will be cut off from its nation.
Now if any person sins in error from amongst the people of the land by doing one of the forbidden commandments of God and incurs guilt; or it is made known to him the sin that he sinned, he is to bring an offering a female goat for the sin whereby he sinned.
As is clear from the first passage, if a person desecrates Shabbat
on purpose, he is to be killed or to suffer karet – being cut off from the Jewish people. An accidental desecration would obligate the sinner to bring a sacrifice.
According to the accepted halakhah
, accidental transgressions that take place on Shabbat
over a period of several weeks are considered separate acts of Hillul Shabbat
(Desecration of the Sabbath), each of which requires a separate sin-offering
. The discussion on today’s daf
examines which cases of collected transgressions are considered to be one unified action and which are considered separate acts.
According to the Mishnah in Massekhet Shabbat
, there are three types of people who accidentally transgress the rules of Shabbat
1. One who forgets the existence of Shabbat is obligated to bring a single sin-offering, no matter how many times he performs forbidden acts on Shabbat.
2. A person who is aware of the concept of Shabbat, but does not know on which day Shabbat falls must bring a sin-offering for each Shabbat that he violated.
3. One who knows that today is Shabbat, but is not aware what activities are forbidden on Shabbat will be obligated to bring a separate sacrifice for each forbidden act that he performed.